Philosophers of religion have always been interested in proofs for the exist ence of god, and many of the arguments in the history of the discipline, such as the. God is the best explanation of our immediate experience and knowledge of his existence. If god exists, and shows himself to some people in religious experiences, then the. Swinburnes classic attempt to apply bayes theorem to the hypothesis god exists is a masterful example of inductive argument. The existence of god based on religious experience free. Martin in his book religious belief outlines the argument from rel. However, our understanding of the term is important in investigating the concept. Proofs for the existence of god queensborough community college. Martin in his book religious belief outlines the argument from religious ex. However, they are not always clear whether religious experience is merely a feeling or a cognitive experience.
Can religious experience provide justification for the belief. Ammunition for the coming war with atheists will be free to download in kindle, oct 2125 in launching his newest book, amazon bestselling. Jun 16, 2014 so religious belief, or even religious experience, becomes impossible in a way that is more profound than even the obvious and overwhelming fact of the suffering of innocents in the extermination. I dont accept intelligent design because you cant prove god exists. Religious experience, argument for the existence of god. Do religious experiences prove the existence of god. After all, scientific rationalists are supposed to care deeply about evidence. Argument from religious experience 1291 words 123 help me. I was surprised to find that there was scientific evidence for the existence of god.
Counter evidence may take various forms the fact of pain and suffering may seem. The cosmological argument successfully demonstrates that god must exist. A direct experience of god makes them certain that god exists so many people claim to have experienced god that his existence must be proved, since they cant all be wrong some religious experiences create a huge change to a persons life eg. He completely avoids any a priori attempt to prove gods existence, such as the. As and alevel revisionjoin george and john as they discuss and debate different philosophical ideas, today they will be looking into religious experiences. It is argued that if someone feels they have experienced god, this will be the most convincing. The first argument begins with the fact that there is change and argues that there must be an unmoved mover that originates all change or motion but is itself unmoved. Lewis asserts that the existence of a universal moral conscience, consistent across time and cultures, can only be explained by the existence of a god who created us. Copleston argues that the existence of religious experiences doesnt prove that god exists, but does make his existence more likely as an explanation. It holds that the best explanation for religious experiences is that they constitute. A religious experience has significance for the person who experiences it. Russell argues that religious experiences are subjective experiences they take place in the mind and do not correspond to anything that exists in reality. Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.
It is not reasonable for anyone to reject clear evidence of religious experience just because they started form a position of scepticism. Pascals wager is not strictly an argument for gods existence. Similar to the subjective arguments for the existence of god, subjective arguments against the supernatural mainly rely on the testimony or experience of witnesses, or the propositions of a revealed religion in general the witness argument gives credibility to personal witnesses, contemporary and from the past, who disbelieve or strongly doubt the existence of god. Also, testimony about the experience may even provide grounds for belief in god for those who do not have such experiences themselves. To others, such emotionbased beliefs can only reflect crowdinduced illusions or personally generated delusioneach the triumph of hope over reason. A religious experience is when someone feels they have had a direct or personal experience of god. Aug 30, 2017 in combination with other evidences for gods existence, direct religious experience and testimony about such an experience may provide strong motivation for believing in god. I mean, real evidence that shows beyond a shadow of a doubt that there is a god. Religious experience has been a contentious subject for philosophers of religion in trying to actually define what a religious experience is, along with psychologists and religious believers. Everyone experiences an internal sense of moral obligation to do the right thing.
After that first book, i found other books with more scientific evidence. He calls the book the varieties of religious illusion, a nod to william jamess varieties of religious experience. The first argument begins with the fact that there is change and argues that there must be an unmoved mover that originates all change or motion but is. Religious epistemology internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Religious experience argument the existence of god. The argument from religious experience is an argument for the existence of god. Teresa of avila, who had divine visions and felt god s presence this made her overwhelmed with. Proofs for the existence of god are highly certain, but they still have some significant uncertainty. As he discusses the various arguments for the existence of god, he implies that ones religious experien evans summarizes much of philosophy of religion, particularly with a christian audience in mind. But if we assume that its quite likely god exists, then religious experiences are much more likely to be true and they could prove god exists. In 36 arguments for the existence of god, goldstein shows that philosophers and scholars may c.
The philosophical evaluation of religious experience jstor. For ma ny religious people there is in the center of their religious nature the feeling that there is something more than their individual consciousness could contact. Some people might challenge this assertion, saying that such an experience could easily be an illusion or an emotional or psychological fantasy. The first edition was published in 1979, and, deservedly, it has been hailed as something of a modern classic. These arguments have been important in the shaping of our understanding of god, but in an important way, they miss the point. He must be more real to you than all the objects of the world. Religious experience and the burden of proof oxford scholarship. So these thinkers do not explicitly formulate any argument from religious experience, that is, the argument that the occurrence of religious experience provides grounds or justification for the existence of god. They report a certainty of knowing, deeper and more sure than any ordinary perception. Many people have been led to believe its impossible to prove the existence of god, but nothing could be further from the truth. We might assume that it can mean anything from saying a prayer, to attending a service at a place of worship, to hearing the voice of god. The existence of god what we call religious experience can differ greatly. Dec 07, 2015 a personal experience with god is evidence of his reality.
Religious experience argument the existence of god gcse. Revelation humans experience the deity through an act of the deity in which the deity reveals itself. A person may say they had personally seen, heard or felt god. Religious experience and the existence of god by richard swinburne. The christian faith is based upon evidence god and. Jan 26, 2021 the argument from religious experience is an inductive argument. Reviews of books with scientific evidence that god exists x. Those arguments to prove the existence of god based on experience are. The existence of god based on religious experience free essay. One reason that modernday debates between atheists and religious believers.
Critically compare corporate religious experiences with individual. A new book entitled scientific evidence god exists. Oct 15, 2015 chapter 5 religious and mysticalchapter 5 religious and mystical experienceexperience for the last three chapters we have been considering arguments for the existence of god. The author, qureshi, recounts his dramatic and inspiring journey from islam to christianity. The existence of god based on religious experience essay. The occurrence of such historical evidence of miracles and religious experiences is the final kind of evidence put forward in the cumulative argument of this book. Nov 29, 2015 simply put, the god the cosmological argument wants to prove exists has to be a necessary, not a contingent, being. In contrast to the classical arguments for the existence of god, namely the ontological, cosmological and teleological arguments, the argument from religious experience doesnt just entail a set logical of points arriving at a conclusion on a piece of paper, rather it also necessitates sensebased experience, tangible to the individual who experiences the divine. Assess the claim that religious experiences prove that god exists. Nonstandard arguments for gods existence introduction to. Aif a certain kind of religious experience occurred it may prove to that person or persons involved that a god was real. Analyse the argument for the existence of god from religious experience a religious experience offers a sense of the ultimate and an awareness of wholeness, a consciousness of the infinite and an absolute dependence. The one theology book all atheists really should read religion.
But all who have genuinely experienced an encounter with god know better. It does not just include spirituality, but also a theme of reliable investigation to what made christianity different to other religions. Religious experience stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Throughout the book, he tends to give much weight to religious experience as a major factor in justifying ones belief in god. The term religious experience can conjure up a wide and diverse series of images. On our total evidence theism is more probable than not. Even beyond the details of what is experienced, however, the subjective experience itself the socalled universal experience of nearness.
One can only perceive that which exists, and so god must exist because there are those that have experienced him. Those who believe that religious experiences are proof of gods existence usually argue inductively and look at the subjective testimonies of individuals to draw similar conclusions from their experiences that can only be explained in terms of the existence of god. Five religious experience, and the affirmation of god. Can religious experience provide justification for the. Teleological argument considering the apparent order of the universe. This article is taken from the apologetics study bible. Here, then, we move to a still better principle of causality. Mar 08, 2017 according to the moral argument, there is a universal human moral conscience which suggests basic human similarities.
The best arguments for gods existence dont challenge. If one accepts that there is indeed such an objective god lying behind the religious experience, what can be said about him. Summa theologic the five ways in this reading aquinas presents his five a posteriori arguments for the existence of god. After over 40 years of not believing that god exists, i was dared by a christian friend to read a book. Deep reflection over what i have said in this book would convince even a confirmed atheist that god exists. Arguing the existence of god from religious experience.
Oct 21, 2019 a new book entitled scientific evidence god exists. Model essays for ocr gce religious studies philosophical. List of possible questions for 2018 philosophy of religion. The argument from religious experience the argument from religious experience is the argument that personal religious experiences can prove god s existence to those that have them. In fact, god is the most powerful reality there is. Cosmological argument considering the existence of the universe. Religious experience and the existence of god by richard. Personal testimony can never be reliable evidence for god s existence. Science might be able at some point to explain these experiences with no. However, religion is the worship of godnot scientific proof of godso we are caught between two very.
Russell argues that religious experiences are subjective experiences they take place in the mind and do not correspond to anything that exists. It is concluded that swinburnes cumulative case for the existence of god fails. Aug 31, 2017 as a bestselling book, seeking allah, finding jesus is a unique approach to proving christianity. The one theology book all atheists really should read. Assess the extent to which the ontological argument fails to prove that god exists analytically. Gerard verschuuren is a excellent, short and clear book that lives up to its title, and then some. If the hypothesis succeeds in offering a simpler, more powerful, comprehensive explanation that has the best fit with our background knowledge, then this book provides a powerful argument for the existence of god.
Understood in this way, one cant even say that god exists in the sense. Dawkins hasnt really disproved the argument from religious experience at all. Religious experience does it prove the existence of god. Back in 2005 a theistic evolutionist blogger, darwin catholic, objected to intelligent design saying, i dont think you can prove god s existence using science. There is a sense of something more or bigger than anything in the known universe. It should at least provide motivation for exploring other evidence for gods existence. If a persons religious experience of god counts as evidence f. Now customize the name of a clipboard to store your clips. A religious experience sometimes known as a spiritual experience, sacred experience, or mystical experience is a subjective experience which is interpreted within a religious framework. Some reports exist of supernatural happenings that it would be difficult to explain from a rational, scientific point of view. In that sense, among others, the book remains a central work in the philosophy of religion, even as it promises to transform what we mean by the phrase. Aug 31, 2012 the aspects of religious experience that wettstein uncovers seem at once more essential and more authentic to the phenomenon as we know it than the familiar metaphysical doctrines.
William james argument religious studies revision world. James analysed forms of experience including conversion, prayer and saintliness. Mystics from around the world report encounters with the divine, as well as experiences of body and mind that are highly unusual. It holds that the best explanation for religious experiences is that they constitute genuine experience or perception of a divine reality. The concept originated in the 19th century, as a defense against the growing rationalism of western society. Philosophy of religion goodreads meet your next favorite book. Religious experience is an encounter of a human being with a supernatural being, be it a deity or an emissary or intermediary for the deity, nevertheless a spiritual it is a numinal experience. Religious experiences can be characterized generally as experiences that seem. The argument from inconsistent revelations contests the existence of the deity called god as described in scripturessuch as the hindu vedas, the jewish tanakh, the christian bible, the muslim quran, the book of mormon or the bahai aqdasby identifying apparent contradictions between different scriptures, within a single scripture, or. Religious experiences loosely described as coming into contact with the divine.
Richard swinburne is one of the foremost current philosophers of religion, and, as he states in his preface, this book is the central book of all that he is written in the field. What should i do about it endeavour to realise him. In combination with other evidences for gods existence, direct religious experience and testimony about such an experience may provide strong motivation for believing in god. To some, personal religious experience is the best evidence of the existence of god. Religious experience for james is at the heart of religion whereas religious teachings, practices and attitudes are second hand religion. Religious experiences are nothing more than forms of psychological neurosis. In expounding the argument from religious experience, he makes. God is the best explanation for the core of historical facts accepted by most ancient historians across the ideological spectrum. The 10 best books that prove christianity is true becoming. Various reasons have been offered for and against accepting this contention. This book contends that, if god exists, some evidence for this existence. Can a religious experience show that there is a god. Weaknesses of the argument it is impossible to prove that these experiences are real. What is the personal experience argument for gods existence.
378 868 758 1190 160 1545 1332 590 1122 395 150 173 272 1561 536 233 1288 534 175 179 1253 247 1037